Skip to content

How good are fund managers?

September 13, 2010

Every Sunday, financial daily The Hindu Business Line (BL) publishes an interesting section called ‘Basket of X’ in its Investment world page. Every week, BL invites a fund manager from a leading fund house (it calls it ‘X’) and allows him to pick 5 stocks of his choice that he thinks will give best returns in a week going forward. BL does not reveal the name of this fund manager and instead calls him ‘Don Diego De La Vega’. Set of these five stocks, selected by Don Diego (Fund Manager), is called the ‘Basket of X’. Then there is another basket of 5 stocks that are randomly selected by BL. Next week, this Basket of X is compared with the basket of random selection, based on the return generated by them in one week time. Whichever basket generates higher return is the winner of the week.

Source: The Hindu Businessline

I have compiled this year’s (till 12th Sept 2010) Don Diego’s performance over random selections. It is interesting to note that most of the time these fund managers (Don Diego) have underperformed the random selections. To be precise, out of a total of 36 times, Random selections have managed to beat Don Diegos’ selections 21 times, whereas Don Diegos have managed to beat random selections only 15 times. Also out of these 36 performances, 16 times Don Diegos’ selections have generated negative returns. In contrast, random selections have given negative returns only 11 times.
Though I am not trying to prove anything here, but the question here is that how good are our so called financial market wizards/fund managers. Looking at the Don Diego’ track record we can say that Efficient Market theorists have some merits in their arguments. Especially the one where they say, capital market experts (read fund managers) are good for nothing!

Week Don Diego’s Return (%) Random Selection Return (%) Winner
5th Sept -0.03 0.16 Random
29th Aug -3.88 3.17 Random
22nd Aug -5.99 2.67 Random
15th Aug -2.46 6.17 Random
8th Aug 0.51 1.7 Random
1st Aug 1.24 -3.82 DonDiego
25th July -9.3 0.8 Random
18th July 1.35 0.09 DonDiego
11th July 1.5 2.2 Random
4th July 0.17 4.5 Random
27th June 1.02 1.12 Random
20th June 1.86 -0.89 DonDiego
13th June 0.77 -0.03 DonDiego
6th June 1.8 1.64 DonDiego
30th May 2.09 0.3 DonDiego
23rd May -4.56 -4.26 Random
16th May 4.5 1.6 DonDiego
9th may -5.29 -0.16 Random
2nd May 1.52 -1.43 DonDiego
25th April 0.87 1.14 Random
18th April -3.31 -0.34 Random
11th April -1.09 2.89 Random
4the April -1.6 1.32 Random
28th Mar -1.93 3.55 Random
21st Mar 1.05 -0.78 DonDiego
14th Mar -4.22 0.42 Random
7th Mar 3.42 3.24 DonDiego
28th Feb 0.72 0.35 DonDiego
21st Feb -1.95 -0.44 Random
14th Feb 5.81 0.65 DonDiego
7th Feb -1 -0.38 Random
31st Jan -5.85 -5.7 Random
24th Jan -3.81 -6.91 DonDiego
17th Jan 1.56 0.35 DonDiego
10th Jan 6.93 4.19 DonDiego
3rd Jan 0.57 2.98 Random
No comments yet

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: